What Size of Kidney Cyst Is Dangerous? Why Its Walls Matter More Than Size

kidney-cyst-ultrasound-consultation-feature-img
Table of Contents

Medical disclaimer. This article is educational and does not replace advice from your own doctor.

If a CT, full body scan or ultrasound found a cyst on your kidney, the report probably gives its size in millimeters or centimeters. The natural question is what size of kidney cyst is dangerous. The authors of the 2019 update to the Bosniak classification, the system radiologists use to grade cysts, say no size cutoff separates benign cysts from cancer.

The same authors note that size may still matter when doctors plan follow-up. The grade rests on how the cyst looks inside, such as its wall thickness and whether any part takes up contrast dye. Most kidney cysts are simple, with a thin wall and water-like fluid, and RadiologyInfo says they typically cause no symptoms or harm.

Kidney Cyst Size Versus Grade

  • The 2019 Bosniak classification grades a cyst’s features and leaves size out.
  • Guidance generally pairs classes I and II with no follow-up, IIF with repeat imaging, and III and IV with a urology consultation.
  • A cyst seen without contrast may need a contrast CT or MRI to be graded.

How Radiologists Grade a Kidney Cyst

The radiologist who reads your scan grades the cyst with the Bosniak classification, which has sorted cystic kidney masses by cancer risk for more than 30 years. Cancer risk rises as a cyst looks more complex, and the 2019 Bosniak update defines terms like thin and thick in millimeters.

Bosniak Classes and Usual Next Steps

  • I

    What it looks like

    Water-like fluid, smooth wall 2 mm or thinner

    How likely cancer is

    Benign

    Typical next step

    No follow-up needed

  • II

    What it looks like

    One to three thin inner walls, calcium, or dense uniform fluid

    How likely cancer is

    Reliably benign

    Typical next step

    Generally no follow-up

  • IIF

    What it looks like

    Four or more thin inner walls, or 3 mm walls, taking up contrast

    How likely cancer is

    Large majority benign

    Typical next step

    Imaging at 6 and 12 months, yearly to 5 years

  • III

    What it looks like

    Thick (4 mm or thicker) or irregular walls that take up contrast

    How likely cancer is

    Intermediate probability

    Typical next step

    Consider a urology consultation

  • IV

    What it looks like

    A nodule, a bump on a wall that takes up contrast

    How likely cancer is

    Large majority malignant

    Typical next step

    Consider a urology consultation

Descriptions follow the Bosniak classification, version 2019, for people without an inherited kidney cancer syndrome. Next steps draw on its suggested report wording, its authors’ expectations and the American College of Radiology’s 2018 white paper, and your doctor may advise otherwise.

When a cyst has features of more than one class, the radiologist assigns the highest. The 2019 Bosniak paper notes that the grade estimates the chance of cancer but cannot tell an aggressive cancer from a slow-growing one. Cystic masses are also more likely than solid ones to be benign.

An older report may use the 2005 version, which put dense, uniform masses over 3 cm that do not take up contrast in class IIF. Version 2019 dropped that size rule, its authors having seen no cancer in such masses when truly uniform. It also moves more masses into lower-risk classes, so older grades can differ.

A Look Beyond Your Kidneys

Our low-dose CT images your heart, lungs and abdomen in one visit.

Book a Full Body Scan

What a Kidney Cyst’s Size Tells You

The answer to what size of kidney cyst is dangerous depends on the features the radiologist grades, since no size cutoff decides the class. The 2019 Bosniak paper leaves size and growth rate out of its classes. Small masses may be cancer and large ones benign, though smaller ones are more likely benign.

Kidney Cyst Size Chart

  • 5 mm

    0.5 cm

  • 10 mm

    1 cm

  • 20 mm

    2 cm

  • 25 mm

    2.5 cm

  • 50 mm

    5 cm

  • 100 mm

    10 cm

A 5 cm reading tells you how large the cyst is today, but it cannot tell you the class or whether the cyst needs treatment. NIDDK, part of the National Institutes of Health, says in its guide to simple kidney cysts that they range from pea to golf ball size. It adds that a simple cyst usually needs no further testing or treatment.

Words on Your Report, in Plain English

A few simple cysts differ from polycystic kidney disease (PKD), a genetic disorder in which clusters of cysts can impair kidney function, according to RadiologyInfo’s page on renal cysts. Kidney stones, hard, pebble-like pieces formed from minerals in urine, are another finding, and we cover imaging for kidney stones separately.

  • Simple. RadiologyInfo says simple cysts without symptoms are usually left alone and need no further tests.
  • Complex or complicated. A thicker wall or solid material, which RadiologyInfo says likely means more imaging. The 2019 Bosniak paper discourages both words, so ask for the Bosniak class.
  • Septa or septation. Inner walls that divide a cyst. Their number and thickness help set the class.
  • Calcification or calcified. Calcium in the wall or septa. Alone it predicts little, so version 2019 counts it as a class II feature, though thick calcium can hide features MRI may show.
  • Hyperdense or hyperattenuating. Dense on CT, measured in Hounsfield units (HU). Version 2019 puts a uniform one of 70 HU or more without contrast in class II, but suggests MRI first above 3 cm.
  • Enhancement or enhancing. Tissue that takes up contrast dye. An enhancing nodule defines class IV, so ask whether any part enhances.
  • Too small to characterize. A 2021 paper by several 2019 authors puts a uniform, low-density one under 1 cm, without nodules, septa or calcium, in class II, which generally needs no follow-up.

Why a Cyst Found Without Contrast May Need Another Scan

If your cyst was seen on a scan without contrast, your doctor may need another scan before the radiologist can grade it. The American College of Radiology (ACR) says in its 2020 appropriateness criteria that CT without and with IV (intravenous) contrast is usually needed to evaluate a cystic mass. Enhancing walls, septa or nodules are key to the Bosniak estimate.

The HU number shows how dense a cyst’s contents are. Under version 2019, a uniform mass with a thin, smooth wall at minus 9 to 20 HU on CT without contrast can be class II with no further imaging. The ACR criteria count a uniform mass under 20 or over 70 HU as benign, and one between 20 and 70 HU as needing more evaluation.

For more imaging, RadiologyInfo lists three common tests, considered equivalent, so usually only one is done. The ultrasound option uses contrast, unlike a standard ultrasound. The others are an abdominal CT or an abdominal MRI, each with and without IV contrast. CT can also help tell benign cysts from tumors.

What Usually Happens Next for Each Class

Your doctor, or a urologist for the higher classes, decides what happens next. For classes I and II, the chart follows the 2019 Bosniak paper and the ACR’s 2018 white paper on incidental kidney masses. NIDDK notes that a doctor may still order regular ultrasounds of a simple cyst to watch for change.

For class IIF, the 2019 Bosniak paper’s suggested wording generally calls for imaging at 6 and 12 months, then yearly for a total of 5 years. The ACR white paper, written for the 2005 version, suggests scans every 6 months at first, then yearly, for at least 5 years. It adds that no definitive study has settled the schedule.

The 2019 Bosniak paper says the true rate of cancer in IIF masses is unknown. Citing studies of the earlier classification, it adds that about 10% show progression and that those progressing are about 85% likely to be malignant. Follow-up therefore looks for change in structure, which the ACR white paper defines as more septa, a thicker wall or septa, or a new solid nodule.

A urologist weighs the options for classes III and IV. The ACR white paper recommends referring both classes for treatment because of a high likelihood of cancer. For class IV, the 2019 Bosniak paper generally expects removal or ablation to be considered.

Class III is less settled. The 2019 Bosniak paper calls the choice between watching and treatment unclear in otherwise healthy people. The ACR white paper accepts watching class III in people with limited life expectancy, other illnesses or high surgical risk.

The American Urological Association’s 2021 guideline on kidney masses suspicious for cancer says active surveillance, with possible later treatment, should be considered for mostly cystic class III and IV lesions. It asks for a shared decision weighing treatment risks and other causes of death against cancer benefits.

When a Kidney Cyst Causes Symptoms

Most simple kidney cysts cause no symptoms, which NIDDK gives as the reason doctors often find them on scans for something else. It lists five problems a simple cyst can cause in rare cases and advises raising any of them with a health care professional.

  • Pressure on organs. A cyst can grow large enough to press on bones or other organs, causing pain or discomfort.
  • Blocked flow. A large cyst can block blood or urine flow through the kidneys or the ureters.
  • An infection. Infection can cause fever, pain and tenderness.
  • A burst cyst. Bursting can cause pain or blood in the urine, called hematuria.
  • High blood pressure. A cyst can also raise blood pressure.

When a Kidney Cyst Needs Treatment

Treatment is for cysts that cause symptoms or harm kidney function, according to RadiologyInfo. In sclerotherapy, an ultrasound-guided needle drains the cyst and injected alcohol hardens the inside so it is less likely to refill. A larger cyst may need laparoscopic surgery to drain it and remove its outer layer. NIDDK gives no size for large, so a number on your report does not by itself point to surgery.

How a Full Body Scan Fits With Your Cyst Follow-Up

A full body scan does not replace your doctor’s plan for a cyst. Craft Body Scan does not use contrast in its process. Our scan can find a kidney cyst, but a contrast study ordered by your own doctor may be needed to class it. Your doctor stays in charge of the cyst.

Our scan looks at the rest of your health. A board-certified radiologist reviews every scan, examining the kidneys, lungs, liver, pancreas and other organs for health problems a CT scan can find. Our guide to what a full body scan shows covers incidental findings, and all eight of our centers offer the scan with a calcium score.

Common Questions About Kidney Cysts

Is a 2.5 cm Kidney Cyst Considered Large?

The Bosniak classification has no cutoff for large, so a 2.5 cm cyst is graded by its features. A Mayo Clinic study imaged 1,948 healthy potential kidney donors with contrast CT. Among those aged 50 to 75, 22% had a cyst of 10 mm or more and 7.8% had one of 20 mm or more. A 2.5 cm (25 mm) cyst falls in the second group.

How Quickly Do Kidney Cysts Grow?

Two Japanese studies of 45 and 61 patients, followed for about 6 and 10 years, found simple cysts grew 2.82 mm and 1.6 mm a year on average. In the first, cysts grew faster under age 50 (3.94 mm a year) than at 50 and older (1.84 mm). The 2019 Bosniak paper says change in a followed cyst’s structure matters more than change in its size.

Can an Ultrasound Tell If a Kidney Cyst Is Cancerous?

Ultrasound can confirm a simple cyst, but its role beyond that is less certain. The 2019 Bosniak paper says standard ultrasound can diagnose a class I cyst that shows no echoes, smooth borders and strong sound transmission. Others generally need a renal mass CT or MRI, except perhaps those with a few thin septa.

When Should I Worry About a Kidney Cyst?

NIDDK advises talking with a health care professional if a simple cyst causes symptoms such as pain, fever or blood in the urine. RadiologyInfo adds pain between the ribs and pelvis and changes in urinary habits as signs of rare complications such as infection, bleeding or enlargement.

What Does Bosniak 2F Mean?

Bosniak 2F is another way to write class IIF, where the F stands for follow-up. The 2019 Bosniak paper’s suggested report wording says the large majority are benign and nearly all malignant ones are slow-growing. The ACR white paper, written for the 2005 version, calls a class IIF mass unchanged for at least 5 years stable and likely of no clinical significance.

Are Kidney Cyst Symptoms Different in Women?

Neither the NIDDK nor the RadiologyInfo page gives symptom information specific to women or men. What differs by sex is how common cysts are. NIDDK says men are more likely than women to develop simple kidney cysts. A Japanese ultrasound screening study of 17,914 people found cysts in 13.0% of men and 5.8% of women.

Your Next Step After a Kidney Cyst Finding

The 2019 Bosniak paper calls the system a guide that radiologists may depart from using clinical judgment in individual patients. Age, other illnesses, life expectancy, preferences and risk tolerance also shape a treatment plan. If you wonder what size of kidney cyst is dangerous, put these questions to the doctor who ordered your scan.

  • The grade. Which Bosniak class did the radiologist assign?
  • The version. Was it graded under version 2019 or the older 2005 version?
  • Contrast and more imaging. Was contrast used, and is a contrast CT or MRI needed?
  • Earlier scans. Are there earlier scans to compare, and has the cyst changed?
  • The follow-up schedule. If follow-up is needed, how often and for how long?
  • A urology referral. Should you see a urologist?

No Referral Needed to Book

Your doctor keeps managing the cyst while we add a wider look, for $2,495, private pay.

Plan a Full Body Scan

 

Share This Article

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Table of Contents

Share This Article